Colton Haynesis ready to cause double trouble.

Haynes, 34, plays twin criminals Steve and Mitch Johnson in Lifetime’sSwindler Seduction. The Johnson brothers trick women into spending money on them, with Louisa (Gabrielle Graham) landing in their sights.

“Steve had led me straight to Mitch and now I can expose both of them,” Louisa can be heard saying in PEOPLE’s exclusive sneak peek.

Lifetime

Swindler Seduction Colton Hayes

Louisa’s first encounter is with Steve, who after having a fast connection with after meeting at a bar in Chicago, suddenly disappears. After finding out she’s pregnant while getting no help from the police, Louisa begins her mission to track Steve down — and finds outhe has a twin brother.

Mitch is later seen visiting Steve in prison.

Swindler Seduction Colton Hayes

Mitch asks his brother while speaking through prison phone glass: “What did I tell you about cleaning up your messes you moron?”

Steve reminds him that they are identical twins and adds, “If I’m a moron, you’re a moron. We’re the same.”

Swindler Seduction Colton Hayes

Mitch takes control of the conversation as he quickly tells his brother: “We are demonstrably not.”

Swindler Seduction Colton Hayes

Never miss a story — sign up forPEOPLE’s free daily newsletterto stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from juicy celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.

source: people.com